This is a bit of a time-consuming glitch due to its repetitive nature, but its reward is well worth it!

Create a wrestler and set your attributes to a comfortable setting for yourself. Begin Story Mode with the created wrestler and play your first match. Try to get as many points as you can. Add them where you wish, save your game, and exit Story Mode.

Next, go back into the Create-a-Wrestler section. Select your wrestler, then select "Copy" and make a copy of the character on an empty slot. Your copy will have the new attributes from your match. Now go back to story mode, select "New" and choose the copy.

You can do this as many times as you wish and each time you will gain more and more attribute points, allowing you to place your points at the level they were at when you finished the first game! (Or, for DoR newbies, it's a great way to put your character on level with the other main-eventers!).