Earlier this week, Harmonix sued Activision... then withdrew the suit. This issue isn't finished, however, and it's over more than just bad blood for instrument controller compatibility.
by David Radd on Wednesday, March 12, 2008
According to a report in Variety, Harmonix Music Systems filed suit against Activision on Monday for $14.5 million in Guitar Hero royalties. However, the Viacom-owned company withdrew the suit on Tuesday night, with the Activision negotiations to continue out of court.
The dispute boils down to an agreement made with RedOctane (now owned by Activision). The deal stated that Harmonix would receive a higher royalty rate if any Guitar Hero sequel used Harmonix technology in any way. However, Harmonix was paid a lower royalty rate, which doesn't sit well with the music game developer.
"(Activision) has failed to pay Harmonix its full share of royalties earned in connection with Harmonix's essential and undisputed contributions of its intellectual property and technology to the bestselling video game Guitar Hero III," said the suit.
Activision, for its part, asserts that it has paid Harmonix the appropriate amount of royalties for Guitar Hero. "Activision believes it has made sufficient payments to Harmonix and the claims otherwise do not have merit," said General Counsel George Rose.
Along with the money derived from retail sales, Harmonix asserts it has not been compensated for money received from song downloads and in-game advertising. With more Guitar Hero products planned in the future, Harmonix wants to stake its claim now. At the current royalty rate, Harmonix says that it will be denied "tens of millions of dollars per year" that it believes it is owed.
GameDaily


